Skip to content
pubscout

Compare

The strongest value in each row is marked.

Attributefile_selector_macos

macOS implementation of the file_selector plugin

pub.devRemove
utopia_save_file

Unified and correct implementation of file saving across platforms.

pub.devRemove
ScoresHealth82 (best)73
Maintenance90 (best)88
Quality9196 (best)
Popularity63 (best)17
Community80 (best)58
Compatibility79100 (best)
UsageDownloads (30 days)2.2M (best)1k
Likes15 (best)11
Pub points140 / 160150 / 160 (best)
GitHub stars5.3k (best)26
MaintenanceLatest release0.9.5+2, 5 weeks ago0.2.6, 3 weeks ago (best)
Major versions in 12 months00
Contributors100+ (best)4
Publisherflutter.devutopiasoft.io
FitPlatformsmacOSAndroid, iOS, Web, macOS
WASM-readyYesYes
KindPlugin (native code)Plugin (native code)
Code generationNoNo
Direct dependencies3 (best)7
LicenseBSD-3-CLAUSEBSD-2-CLAUSE
Setup effortLowLow
JudgementStrengths
  • Native macOS integration
  • Supports entitlements for read/write access
  • Keeps up with latest Flutter SDKs
  • No extra pubspec dependency needed when using file_selector
  • Provides a unified interface for saving files on Android, iOS, macOS, and Web
  • Automatically infers MIME types and handles extension matching
  • Requires no special storage permissions on Android or property list changes on iOS
Weaknesses
  • Only works on macOS
  • Requires adding entitlements to the app bundle
  • No support for other platforms
  • Web downloads complete immediately via anchor elements even if the user cancels later
  • Platform behavior varies significantly (system files app on Android, share sheet on iOS, save panel on macOS)
Warnings
  • Native setup
  • Native setup
file_selector_macos vs utopia_save_file: which Flutter package should you use? | pubscout