Skip to content
pubscout

Compare

The strongest value in each row is marked.

Attributepermission_guard

UI wrapper around permission_handler that simplifies permission state handling.

pub.devRemove
smart_permission

Flutter runtime permissions made easy with adaptive dialogs and permission gates.

pub.devRemove
ScoresHealth4671 (best)
Maintenance286 (best)
Quality9197 (best)
Popularity2851 (best)
Community41 (best)6
Compatibility100100
UsageDownloads (30 days)78312k (best)
Likes30 (best)19
Pub points140 / 160160 / 160 (best)
GitHub stars68 (best)
MaintenanceLatest release2.0.1, 2 years ago1.1.0, 4 weeks ago (best)
Major versions in 12 months0 (best)1
Contributors11
Publishereterkit.comUnverified
FitPlatformsAndroid, iOS, Web, WindowsAndroid, iOS, Web, Windows
WASM-readyYesYes
KindFlutter widgetsFlutter widgets
Code generationNoNo
Direct dependencies11
LicenseBSD-3-CLAUSEMIT
Setup effortMediumMedium
JudgementStrengths
  • Easy to integrate with a single widget
  • Highly customizable via PermissionGuardOptions
  • Works on all major platforms supported by permission_handler
  • Handles complex permission flows (denied, permanently denied, restricted) automatically.
  • Includes a PermissionGate widget that re-checks status when returning to the foreground.
  • Provides built-in testing support with FakeSmartPermissionGateway.
Weaknesses
  • Adds another layer on top of permission_handler
  • Limited to features of permission_handler
  • May not cover very specific permission flows
  • Relies on permission_handler and inherits its platform limitations (no macOS or Linux support).
  • Requires platform-specific configuration in AndroidManifest.xml, Info.plist, and optionally Podfile.
WarningsNoneNone
permission_guard vs smart_permission: which Flutter package should you use? | pubscout